Hong Kong, malls and localism

If you’ve ever looked up at the stars and felt insignificant, you’ll understand the feeling of first arriving in Hong Kong. Impossibly high buildings stretch as far as the eye can see, painted in gaudy pastels or layers of age old dirt, whilst masses of people glued to enormous mobile phone screens weave in and out of each other, seemingly effortlessly. Hong Kong is a seething mass of humanity: one part cosmopolitan mega mall, one part traditional Chinese, one part Sci-fi novel.

photo 3

The idea of LOHAS (a Life of Health and Sustainability) is present everywhere. As a reaction to the SARS epidemic of the early 2000s, everything from door handles to escalators are ‘sterilised very four hours’ and you will still see people in paper masks on the MTR (Tube equivalent). Elsewhere, signs extolling the dangers of lifting bulky items abound, parks are neatly divided up into activity or exercise areas and recycling points are present on most street corners. The focus seems mainly on the individual and avoiding harm and I get the sense of a risk averse and paternal culture.

These kinds of signs are found everywhere, from toilets to lifts
These kinds of signs are found everywhere, from toilets to lifts

There are many things that strike me as I get to know the place better: how connected the inhabitants are (signal boosters on the MTR mean that phones are generally permanently out) and how present brands (the same brands) are. Enormous mega malls pervade even the most picturesque and rural parts of the city (there are rumours that it is possible to travel from one end of Kowloon to almost the furthest point of Lantau Island without venturing outside). And shops, advertisements, branding, are everywhere. Contrast this to the busy markets, medicine shops and exotic street food of Mong Kok or the rural bliss of Peng Chau and you have a contrast so marked it takes some convincing to think you’re in the same city.

A street food kitchen in Mong Kok
A street food kitchen in Mong Kok

For the brand is king: fake Mulberry and Michael Kors lines the markets, whilst Mainlanders (the term for the mainland Chinese) reportedly queue to get into the luxury shops in Tst and Central on a busy day. I am struck and shocked by the pervasiveness of the same (western) brands: the sense of inevitability and déjà vu as you ascend from the MTR into yet another mall that looks the same, or try to navigate a route, passing yet another Chanel as you do.

The thing I wonder at is how all of those identical shops can be profitable and financially sustainable. Yet, the malls are growing and taking over: street food stalls and markets are under threat from a government that sees them as unhygienic and outdated. It’s a difficult conundrum for a marketer: on one hand, I work with big brands for their reach and potential to create real change. On the other, I value cultural, architectural and culinary diversity.

As it’s evolved, I’ve always been a little sniffy of the ‘local’ movements in British retail, community groups and politics over the last few years. I’ve tended to view them as conservative, small minded and mildly xenophobic on occasion. However, seeing the result of globalisation and consumerism taken to its logical conclusion, I find myself having more sympathy with both their fears and aspirations. Rumours of such a movement are starting to circulate in Hong Kong and I can’t say I wouldn’t support it.


3 thoughts on “Hong Kong, malls and localism

  1. I’m going to be frank and say that you’re spot on, the HK bubble is chaste, risk adverse and brand obsessed. Local Hong Kongers (born and bred) could not creative themselves out of a cardboard box. Safe thinking and acting is encouraged, and stepping out of the ordinary is not. So happy you see first hand why I felt so suffocated living there 🙂 (Having my whole class of kids squeal simultaneously in disgust when I replaced a water bottle cap because it was exposed to air we breathe did it for me). Loving your blog please keep writing. Xxx

    1. I totally get this, I definitely walked around with rose tinted spectacles and having a local guide was fantastic. The thing I really loved though was that all of the trends you read about were here: wearable technology, the importance of connectedness, the luxury brand as middle class signal mechanism, were all on display. I wonder whether the punk attitude will ever make it here though. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s